The Accidental Major League Tryout
Below is another article in a series of blog entries I’ve written as a candidate for president of Red Sox Nation. This article originally appeared on my other blog at Crawdaddy Cove.
I was a mediocre
pitcher for Brookline High, a 130 lb. reed with infinitely more heart
than talent. Greg McMurtry was the stud of the the state champion
Brockton High School squad, the future Michigan Wolverines legend, #1 draft choice of the Boston Red Sox,
and third round choice of the New England Patriots. In the spring of
1986, for six pitches, the divergent paths of our baseball careers
crossed. It’s funny how vividly I remember that encounter, like a movie
I’ve seen a thousand times…
The day was May 16, 1986. I was playing left field and Brockton’s
lead was something like 19-3. Major league scouts perched along first
and third baseline fences, waiting for another glimpse of McMurtry’s
majesty. I and the rest of the players there that day hungered for a
chance to do something heroic in front of the scouts, to begin our
dream-like march to the bigs and the Baseball Hall of Fame. But by the
sixth and second-to-last inning, it didn’t look like I was going to get
Then, the first three or four Brockton hitters reached base to start
of the bottom of the sixth inning, so I was summoned to the mound to
quash yet another Brockton rally. I remember trotting in from left
thinking, When is McMurtry coming up? As I threw my warm-up
pitches, I overheard a scout ask my coach, "What’s this new guy’s
name?" The last few warm-ups were the hardest fastballs I had ever
The first batter I faced waved his bat at three smoking fastballs, missed them all, and sat down. Holycrap, I thought, I just wasted that guy in front of twenty major league scouts. I’m gonna be a pro! As
I watched the next Brockton player step into the batter’s box, I heard
some scouts buzzing. One, in an Astros cap, help up his radar gun and
pointed it at me. I was being noticed.
The next batter watched the first two fastballs tear by him for
strikes, fouled off a curveball, then swung mightily under a high
heater for strike three. I tried to stay calm. OhmyGod. I’m blowing away the best hitters in the state and twenty major league scouts are watching. I looked over at my father. He was beaming and talking with a rotund man in a Dodgers cap who was holding a clipboard. I’m gonna be a Dodger!
The next batter stroked my first pitch to right field, a clean, line drive base hit. No problem, they’ll forget about that when I nail this next guy. But
I walked him. And the next batter singled, loading the bases. And as
another Brockton batter walked to the plate, I saw the marvelous figure
of Greg McMurtry swagger to the on-deck circle.
He carried a black bat with a red donut on it and stared at me, calm
but fierce, like a panther patiently eyeing a rabbit he wants to maul.
Relaxed, he swung his bat one-handed over his left shoulder, then
switched hands and over his right shoulder, showing beautiful, hard
muscles like in a Michelangelo sculpture. I forced myself to avert my
eyes and focused on my catcher, looking for the signal.
I knew I would fail to retire this batter. That McMurtry would come
to the plate seemed inevitable. I could feel the two of us being tugged
toward confrontation by the strings of fate. (I seriously doubt Greg
felt the same thing.) Sure enough, the batter preceding McMurtry hit a
ground ball that squeaked through the hole between the third baseman
and shortstop. A couple of runners scored, and Greg McMurtry stood at
home plate to give them high-fives.
The scouts adjusted in their lawn chairs and pointed their video
cameras towards the batter’s box. McMurtry stepped to the plate with
the confidence of a superhero. Sweating and trembling, I faced the
awesome challenge standing sixty feet, six inches before me.
The catcher put down two fingers, signaling a curveball. Good idea, he won’t expect that. High,
ball one. I was relieved I had survived the first pitch and I relaxed a
little. Again, the catcher called for a curveball. Ingenious idea, he certainly won’t expect another curveball on a 1-0 count. High, ball two. The catcher tossed the ball back to me as the scouts moaned, worried that I would give McMurtry nothing good to hit and issue him a walk.
Hold on a second, this is Greg McMurtry. Don’t play around with him, I scolded myself. This is your chance for glory, the moment you dreamed of in every wiffle ball game growing up. Wake up and go after him. For Godsakes, don’t walk him! I realized I had made an error of, perhaps, historic proportions in the annals of the Crawford family.
Looking in for the catcher’s signal, I got the sign I wanted, a
single finger, then I blazed a fastball over the outside corner.
"Stee-rike!" yelled the ump. Suddenly, I had a shred of
self-confidence. The count was two and one. I had to throw another
fastball. I knew it, my catcher knew it, and Greg knew it. I threw the
heater, this one with extra juice, right down the heart of the plate.
McMurtry coiled then swung majestically and we all held our breath for
an instant. Thwack! The ball met the catcher’s mitt and Greg
McMurtry, for the first time all day, was mortal, stumbling momentarily
to regain his balance after a frighteningly robust swing. "Stee-rike
Holycrap, I’m one pitch away from striking out Greg McMurtry in front of twenty major league scouts. I
looked over at my coach. He was pacing and smiling, arms crossed,
savoring the possibilities of the next pitch. "Go get him, Robby!" he
said. "One more, one more, kid!" I looked at my father. He smiled at
me, winked, and pumped his right fist. With his left hand, he wiped the
sweat from his forehead. I looked in for the sign. McMurtry leaned in a
little more over the plate to protect the outside corner. The
perspiration on his steel forearms glistened in the sun. The catcher
put down a single finger and I threw the ball as hard as I could.
McMurtry stepped into the pitch but held his swing. Outside and low.
"Full count!" bellowed the umpire, who was obviously auditioning for
the majors, as well. I got the ball back from the catcher and closed my
eyes. Please God, don’t let me walk him, don’t let me walk him. I
glanced over at my dad. He and the Dodgers scout were chuckling, the
scout carelessly and my father nervously. Our eyes met and his seemed
to say, "Oh boy, Rob, you’ve really gotten yourself into a situation
here!" McMurtry started at me. I could tell he wanted a chance to show
those scouts that his futile swing had been a fluke. He wanted to take
The catcher didn’t even bother with a sign. It was fastball all the
way. Just hum it in there and see what happens. I looked at the mitt
and tried to focus. I tried to block out my teammates, the scouts, my
coach, my father, even Greg McMurtry. I tried to block out the full
count and the fact that the next pitch would be remembered and talked
about in my family for years to come, regardless of the result (and it
Then, pulled along in the current of time and fate, I wound up and
delivered my pitch, a fastball that I tried to guide with my will as it
approached home plate. The scouts watched, my father prayed, my coach
grinned, and Greg McMurtry checked his swing as the ball crossed the
outside black of the plate. "Ball four," said the umpire non-chalantly,
rising from his crouch. I shrugged as McMurtry glided toward first
base. He proceeded to steal second before one of his teammates flew out
to end the inning.
I walked Greg McMurtry.
That summer, the Red Sox drafted him in the first round, but he
chose college instead and starred for Bo Schembechler’s Rose
Bowl-winning Michigan Wolverines for four years. He was drafted by the
Detroit Tigers (27th round) and New England Patriots (3rd round) in
1990, and played wide receiver for the Patriots and Bears for five seasons, during which he had 128 receptions for 1,631 yards and five touchdowns. He was out of major pro sports at the age of 27.
I never saw another athletic moment as important or dramatic (to me)
as my 3-2 pitch to Greg McMurtry. That day, that situation, was the
closest I ever came to my dream (and every kid in Red Sox Nation’s
dream) of being drafted by the Boston Red Sox. Greg McMurtry wouldn’t
recognize me if I walked right up to him and introduced myself. But the
image of his chiseled body, his confident glare, and his one elegant,
lusty whiff at a Rob Crawford fastball will be with me always.